Bologna or Florence: where to live, districts compared
Bologna or Florence: 30 addresses, 5 districts in each city. Average score 79.9 against 77.4, noise and minutes to a station side by side.
Score your own address
Everything this article covers, you can check on your own address: free, in a minute.
Free. The score at once, the full report after an e-mail sign-in.
Contents 6 sections
5 districts in each city, 30 addresses
Bologna or Florence is a question behind many moves. We took 5 districts in each city, three addresses in each, and put the same numbers side by side. The cities as a whole are on Where is the best place to live in Bologna and Where is the best place to live in Florence. Measured in Bologna: Historic Centre, Saragozza, Cirenaica, Bolognina and Murri. Measured in Florence: Gavinana, Santa Croce, Campo di Marte, Rifredi and Oltrarno.
For every address we worked out what can be reached on foot. The reports are from 17 and 18 October 2026, with the General profile. Neither city has a metro, so the nearest station is the closest one that the city’s transport offers; the minutes are counted the same way in both cities.
Bologna: 79.9 on average
Historic Centre: 81.5 on average (addresses at 82.2, 82.1 and 80.3). Noise costs from 0 to 3.64 points, the most at Via dell'Indipendenza, 11. A station is 1–3 min away; the closest is Piazza Maggiore-San Pietro. Groceries are 1–6 min away, a school 6–9, a park 5.
Saragozza: 81.0 on average (addresses at 82.3, 80.6 and 80.1). Noise costs from 0 to 1.68 points, the most at Via Luigi Valeriani, 23. A station is 1–3 min away; the closest is XXI Aprile Zannoni. Groceries are 3–7 min away, a school 4–7, a park 4–8.
Cirenaica: 80.9 on average (addresses at 82.1, 81.5 and 79.1). Noise costs from 2.47 to 3.13 points, the most at Via Oreste Regnoli, 12. A station is 2–4 min away; the closest is Cirenaica. Groceries are 2–6 min away, a school 3–6, a park 1–5.
Bolognina: 78.4 on average (addresses at 78.8, 78.5 and 78.0). Noise costs from 7.22 to 7.72 points, the most at Via di Corticella, 54. A station is 1 min away; the closest is Bolognina. Groceries are 2–6 min away, a school 3–4, a park 3–5. The most noise in this comparison.
Murri: 77.4 on average (addresses at 79.4, 76.9 and 75.9). Noise costs from 0 to 4.67 points, the most at Via Augusto Murri, 14. A station is 1–5 min away; the closest is Porta Santo Stefano Rosa Parks. Groceries are 2–5 min away, a school 3–4, a park 2–4.
Florence: 77.4 on average
Gavinana: 82.7 on average (addresses at 85.2, 83.6 and 79.2). Noise costs from 0 to 2.70 points, the most at Via degli Adriani, 30. A station is 1–6 min away; the closest is Giovanni dalle Bande Nere. Groceries are 4–8 min away, a school 6–11, a park 1–3. The highest average in this comparison.
Santa Croce: 82.0 on average (addresses at 83.9, 83.7 and 78.5). No address loses points to noise. A station is 1–3 min away; the closest is Benci. Groceries are 2–5 min away, a school 4–6, a park 3–6.
Campo di Marte: 77.9 on average (addresses at 78.7, 78.1 and 76.9). No address loses points to noise. A station is 1–4 min away; the closest is Fanti Calatafimi. Groceries are 4–7 min away, a school 2–7, a park 1–2.
Rifredi: 75.6 on average (addresses at 82.4, 80.8 and 63.7). Noise costs from 0 to 5.45 points, the most at Via del Terzolle, 97. A station is 2–5 min away; the closest is Madonnina del Grappa. Groceries are 4–9 min away, a school 6–10, a park 3.
Oltrarno: 68.9 on average (addresses at 77.9, 76.2 and 52.7). No address loses points to noise. A station is 1–9 min away; the closest is Piazza San Felice. Groceries are 4–9 min away, a school 2–13, a park 1–5. The lowest average in this comparison.
What the table shows
Over 15 addresses Bologna averages 79.9 and Florence 77.4: a gap of 2.4 points. Best of the ten: Gavinana (Florence), 82.7. Weakest: Oltrarno (Florence), 68.9.
Noise costs Bologna 2.73 points per address on average and Florence 0.73. A station is 2.1 min away on average in Bologna and 3.1 in Florence; a school 4.7 and 6.3 min on foot, a park 4.2 and 2.8.
| Measure | Bologna | Florence |
|---|---|---|
| Average score, 15 addresses | 79.9 | 77.4 |
| Noise, points per address | −2.73 | −0.73 |
| To a station, min | 2.1 | 3.1 |
| To a school, min | 4.7 | 6.3 |
| To a park, min | 4.2 | 2.8 |
| To a grocery, min | 4.1 | 5.3 |
| District | City | Average | Noise | To station, min |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gavinana | Florence | 82.7 | −0.90 | 1–6 |
| Santa Croce | Florence | 82.0 | 0 | 1–3 |
| Historic Centre | Bologna | 81.5 | −1.21 | 1–3 |
| Saragozza | Bologna | 81.0 | −0.56 | 1–3 |
| Cirenaica | Bologna | 80.9 | −2.76 | 2–4 |
| Bolognina | Bologna | 78.4 | −7.55 | 1 |
| Campo di Marte | Florence | 77.9 | 0 | 1–4 |
| Murri | Bologna | 77.4 | −1.56 | 1–5 |
| Rifredi | Florence | 75.6 | −2.76 | 2–5 |
| Oltrarno | Florence | 68.9 | 0 | 1–9 |
Crime is not something we measure; people who live there know more about safety. Rents are not in the table either: they are in the listing.
How to choose
- The higher average: Bologna, 79.9 against 77.4.
- Less noise: Florence, 0.73 against 2.73 points per address.
- The best of the ten: Gavinana (Florence), 82.7.
- No points lost to noise: Santa Croce (Florence), Campo di Marte (Florence) and Oltrarno (Florence).
How to check a flat in Bologna or in Florence
Paste in the address from the listing and read two lines first: the noise, which costs up to 7.72 points here, and the minutes to the nearest station. Two finalists go side by side on the comparison page.
Districts with a page of their own: Gavinana (Florence), Santa Croce (Florence), Historic Centre (Bologna), Saragozza (Bologna), Cirenaica (Bologna), Bolognina (Bologna), Campo di Marte (Florence), Murri (Bologna), Rifredi (Florence) and Oltrarno (Florence). More: Rome or Milan: where to live, districts compared. Other Italian cities are in the Italy rating, and what goes into the score is explained on How it is calculated.
Questions
Bologna or Florence: which has the higher score?
Over 15 addresses Bologna averages 79.9 and Florence 77.4. Best of the ten: Gavinana (Florence), 82.7. Weakest: Oltrarno (Florence), 68.9.
Which city is quieter, Bologna or Florence?
Per address Bologna loses 2.73 points to noise on average and Florence 0.73. Quietest: Santa Croce (Florence), Campo di Marte (Florence) and Oltrarno (Florence), 0. Loudest: Bolognina (Bologna), −7.55.
Bologna or Florence: where is a station closer?
On average the nearest station is 2.1 min away in Bologna and 3.1 min in Florence. Closest: Bolognina (Bologna), 1 min. Farthest: Oltrarno (Florence), 1–9 min.
Which district scored highest in each city?
In Bologna: Historic Centre, 81.5. In Florence: Gavinana, 82.7.

