Centre or suburb: one table for one family
Centre or suburb for a family with a child: central Yekaterinburg and Akademichesky in minutes and with family weights, which erase the 8.4-point gap.
Score your own address
Everything this article covers, you can check on your own address: free, in a minute.
Free. The score at once, the full report after an e-mail sign-in.
Contents 6 sections
One city, two districts, one family
A family with a child is choosing between the centre and a new residential suburb. The centre has the theatre, cafes and the metro by the door. The suburb has a school in the courtyard, roomy flats and quiet. The usual advice is "look at what matters more to you", but to answer that you need a table where both sides are counted the same way.

Below is such a table for Yekaterinburg. The centre against Akademichesky, first in minutes on foot, then by category with the weights of an ordinary resident and with the weights of a family. With family weights, the result flips.
The centre and Akademichesky in minutes
We start with the measured addresses of the districts. For each one we counted the minutes on foot to the nearest groceries, station, school and park.
| Address | District | Groceries | Station | School | Park | Score |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lenin Avenue 51 | Centre | 5 min | 12 min | 3 min | 2 min | 90.7 |
| Vaynera Street 9 | Centre | 3 min | 4 min | 6 min | 6 min | 90.3 |
| Akademika Shvartsa Street 17 | Botanichesky | 2 min | 4 min | 14 min | 2 min | 85.6 |
| Vilgelma de Gennina Street 37 | Akademichesky | 3 min | 34 min | 6 min | 8 min | 78 |
| Krasnolesya Street 133 | Akademichesky | 2 min | 34 min | 9 min | 5 min | 76.9 |
Groceries, the school and the park are close in both districts, a couple of minutes apart. The station decides everything: from Akademichesky it is 34 minutes on foot to Chkalovskaya. For an ordinary resident that is the district's main drawback, and in the General profile it trails the centre by 12–14 points.
A table for one family
Now let us take three addresses from the rating for Russia: 8 Marta Street 46 in the centre, Vilgelma de Gennina Street 40 in Akademichesky and Mashinostroiteley Street 19 in Uralmash. Each has scores for eleven categories. We recalculate them with the weights of the Family with a child profile: education 22 instead of 10, parks and sport 16 instead of 14, health 11 instead of 9, transport 13 instead of 18, cafes and culture 4 instead of 8.
| Address | General profile | With family weights | Education | Transport |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 8 Marta Street 46, Centre | 86.7 | 83.3 | 57.8 | 100 |
| Vilgelma de Gennina Street 40, Akademichesky | 78.3 | 84.0 | 99.14 | 35.88 |
| Mashinostroiteley Street 19, Uralmash | 72.2 | 70.5 | 56.31 | 77.45 |
The 8.4-point gap in favour of the centre disappears, and Akademichesky pulls ahead by 0.7. There is one reason: education. At 8 Marta Street 46 this category scored 57.8, at de Gennina 40 it scored 99.14. With a weight of 10, a 41-point difference in the category is worth 4.1 points of the score; with a weight of 22, it is already 9.1.
Transport works the other way, but more weakly. The centre scores 100, Akademichesky 35.88. With a weight of 18 that is 11.5 points in favour of the centre; with a weight of 13, only 8.3.

What this means for a family
If the family has a school-age child and nobody travels to the centre every day, Akademichesky is no worse than the centre by the table, and better for schools and nurseries. If one of the parents works in the centre, add the commute to the table: the score does not count it, because it does not know where you work.
A rough calculation. Say the trip from Akademichesky to the centre takes 25 minutes longer one way than from the centre. Twice a day, 22 working days: that is more than 18 hours a month. None of this is in the score, so compare the commute separately, on your own route and at rush hour.
Uralmash loses in this table in both profiles. Education 56.31, health 62.39, plus a 3.46-point penalty for the industrial zone nearby. For a family this address is weaker than the others however you count it.
What recalculating the weights leaves out
The recalculation above changes only the weights. A real report with the Family with a child profile changes more: a family walks more slowly, 3.9 km/h instead of 4.8, steps take three times as long, and a school, a playground and a park become essentials. If any of them is beyond the limit, its category loses another 40%.
For the centre that is more likely a minus: at 8 Marta Street 46 education already scored only 57.8, and at a child's pace schools, nurseries and playgrounds will be even further away. For Akademichesky it is more likely a plus, because the school and the park are a few minutes away. So treat the weighted table as a first approximation, and make the final comparison in a report with the family profile.
How to build such a table for yourself
- Pick one real address in each district, ideally from listings you are looking at.
- Score both addresses with the profile that fits your family.
- Put the score and the three or four categories that matter most to you in a table: for a family that is education, parks and sport, health and transport.
- Add the school, nursery or after-school club to My places if you have already chosen them, and compare the minutes to them. Count the commute separately.
- Only then look at flats: the table tells you which district to search in.
The weights of all profiles and the essentials rule are on the How it is calculated page. Yekaterinburg addresses by district are collected on the Yekaterinburg page, and all three addresses from the table are in the rating for Russia.
Questions
Where is it better to live with a child: in the centre or in a suburb?
It depends on the schools and nurseries nearby. In Yekaterinburg the centre wins in the General profile, but with family weights Akademichesky catches up and overtakes it thanks to education.
Does the score take the commute into account?
No, the score does not know where you work. Compare the commute from each district separately, on your own route.
How does the Family with a child profile differ from the General one?
Education weighs 22 points instead of 10, transport 13 instead of 18, the pace is slower, and a school, a playground and a park are essentials.


