Two addresses: choosing by minutes, noise and costs
Comparing two flats in Kazan: 46 Yamasheva Avenue scores 83.7, 72 Fuchika Street 79.1. Where the 4.6 points come from and what they mean for you.
Score your own address
Everything this article covers, you can check on your own address: free, in a minute.
Free. The score at once, the full report after an e-mail sign-in.
Contents 8 sections
When you are down to two flats
By the end of a search there are usually two options left, similar in price and size. Then the arguing over details begins. To stop it going round in circles, break the difference into parts and see which of them actually concern you.

Take two addresses in Kazan. 46 Yamasheva Avenue is in the Novo-Savinovsky district, across the Kazanka river. 72 Yuliusa Fuchika Street is in the Privolzhsky district, in a large housing estate in the south-east. The scores are 83.7 and 79.1. The gap is 4.6 points, and both addresses are in the same band, "Most errands on foot".
Step 1. Where the addresses are equal
First cross out everything where there is no difference. Daily needs: 98 and 99. Public transport: 88 and 92. Education: 90 and 86. Health: 80 and 82. The air penalty is the same, 1.2 points.
The four weightiest everyday categories differ by no more than four points between the two addresses. A shop, a pharmacy, a school, a clinic and a stop are near both, so you can set these lines aside.
Step 2. Where they differ
| Category | Yamasheva 46 | Fuchika 72 | Share of the score gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cafes and culture | 88 | 44 | +3.5 |
| Remote work | 37 | 18 | +0.2 |
| Bikes and car sharing | 31 | 21 | +0.3 |
| Parks and sport | 85 | 94 | −1.3 |
| Street network | 75 | 83 | −1.1 |
| Noise penalty | 0 | −3.52 | +3.5 |
Two lines account for almost the whole difference. Cafes, cinemas and libraries: 88 at Yamasheva, 44 at Fuchika. With a category weight of 8 that is 3.5 points. The second line is noise: the building on Fuchika has a penalty of 3.52, the one on Yamasheva none.
Parks and the street network itself pull the other way. Fuchika has greenery at 94 against 85 and a street network at 83 against 75. Wide arterial roads cut through the Novo-Savinovsky district, Yamasheva Avenue among them, and a route that looks short on the map more often runs into a crossing.
Everything else, from public transport to pets, gives Fuchika Street back half a point in total, and the result is 4.6.
Step 3. Whose difference is it
What remains is to work out whether these 4.6 points concern you personally.
If you go to a cafe once a month but need a park every day, the first line of the table weighs almost nothing for you and the fourth weighs more. Open the weights panel and move the sliders. With the weights of a family with a child, where education is 22 points, parks 16 and cafes and culture 4, the addresses score 85.1 and 82.1: the gap narrows to three points.
With the weights of remote work it is the other way round: 77 and 68.4, a gap of almost nine points. At the Fuchika building the work category is 18 out of 100 and cafes 44. If you spend the whole day in the neighbourhood, there is nowhere to sit with a laptop.
For someone without a car the two addresses are about as good as each other: 84.9 and 81.7.
| Set of weights | Yamasheva 46 | Fuchika 72 | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| General profile | 83.7 | 79.1 | 4.6 |
| As a family with a child | 85.1 | 82.1 | 3.0 |
| As without a car | 84.9 | 81.7 | 3.2 |
| As for remote work | 77.0 | 68.4 | 8.6 |

Step 4. Noise: check it on the spot
A penalty of 3.52 points means a big road runs close to the point where the Fuchika building stands. Which road and how many metres away is written in the block "What lowers the score". At the viewing, the first thing to check is which way the windows face.
If the windows face the courtyard, those 3.52 points hardly apply to you, and the two addresses come within a point of each other. If they face the road, the penalty is fair, and in the evening you will hear it for yourself.
Step 5. The trip to the centre
The trip to the centre barely enters the score, even though you will make it every day. Kazan has a single metro line, and most buildings are far from it. Public transport is high at both addresses, 88 and 92, but that does not mean there is a metro station by the door. The report lists exactly which lines are nearby.
By bike, Kremlyovskaya Street is 5.8 kilometres from 46 Yamasheva Avenue: 26 minutes, a third of it on cycle tracks. From 72 Fuchika Street it is 12.1 kilometres and 50 minutes. By our formula the first ride scores 61 out of 100, the second 8.
If you work in the centre, you will feel this difference every day. Add your workplace to the "My places" block: the report will show the direct transit lines from each address and include the place in "your version" of the score.
Step 6. Costs
We do not publish rents, and we have no open official cost-of-living figure for Russian cities. But you can work it out yourself, and it takes one line.
Take the difference in monthly rent. Opposite it, write down what you will have to pay to make up for what the cheaper address lacks. If Fuchika is cheaper: trips to the centre and back, evening trips to wherever the cafes and the cinema are. If Yamasheva is cheaper: perhaps nothing beyond a longer way to the park.
If making up the difference costs less than the gap in rent, the cheaper address really is cheaper. If it costs more, you are paying the same amount, just in time and taxis.
How to do this in five minutes
The comparison page takes two to five addresses. For each category it marks the best and the worst, and the block "Where the difference comes from" breaks the gap between the highest and the lowest score down by category and penalty, as in the table above.
Then open both reports, set the same weights and add the same places of your own. The links keep the settings. Send them to the person you are choosing with, and carry on the argument with numbers.
What lies behind each category is explained on the page How it is calculated. Both Kazan addresses, and a third, 141 Pobedy Avenue, are on the Kazan page.
Questions
How significant is a difference of 4 to 5 points?
It is a third of the width of a band. But it is more useful to see what it is made of: for the Kazan pair almost all of it comes from cafes and noise.
How do I compare two flats for my own habits?
Set the same weights in the weights panel of both reports. With a family's weights the gap between our addresses is three points, with the weights of remote work almost nine.
How many addresses can I compare at once?
From two to five on the comparison page.


