Supermarket or corner shop: which scores higher

A shop by the door or a supermarket nine minutes away: which is worth more? How shop type, minutes and the top three places count, shown in Tbilisi.

Score your own address

Everything this article covers, you can check on your own address: free, in a minute.

Type an address: a street and a house number.

Who is it for

Free. The score at once, the full report after an e-mail sign-in.

Contents 7 sections
  1. A shop downstairs against a supermarket
  2. Quality of a place: supermarket 1, corner shop 0.75
  3. First place matters more than second
  4. Tbilisi: the market is closer, but the supermarket comes first
  5. When there is no shop at all
  6. Bakeries and shopping centres count separately
  7. What the calculation does not know about shops

A shop downstairs against a supermarket

On the ground floor of your building there is a small shop with bread, milk and eggs. The supermarket is nine minutes away. Which address is better for groceries: this one, or the one next door with no shop downstairs but a supermarket five minutes away? Everyone answers in their own way, but the score answers by rules, and the rules are worth knowing.

A small grocery shop on the ground floor of a residential building, with a large supermarket and car park further down the street.

In short: in our calculation the type of shop matters as much as the minutes to it. A supermarket nine minutes away can be worth more than a shop by your door. Below we explain why and look at a real report: 12 Shota Rustaveli Avenue in Tbilisi, 4 October 2026.

Quality of a place: supermarket 1, corner shop 0.75

The grocery shop need accepts places of several kinds, but with different quality. A supermarket is worth 1. A market 0.8. A corner shop, a small grocer and a general store 0.75. A greengrocer, a butcher, a fishmonger, a dairy and a farm shop 0.5 each: you can buy one kind of thing there, but not everything.

The second adjustment is distance. Up to five minutes on foot a shop counts in full; beyond that its value falls smoothly and reaches zero at twenty minutes. In a large city with a metro the limit is further: twenty-five minutes.

The value of a place is its quality multiplied by the share left after the minutes. A corner shop one minute away is worth 0.75 × 1 = 0.75. A supermarket seven minutes away outside a large city is worth 1 × 0.95 = 0.95. At nine minutes it is 0.81. It only becomes worth less than the shop downstairs from about ten minutes, and at twelve it is down to 0.52.

Six bars: a corner shop one minute away is worth 75%, a market one minute away 80%, a supermarket at 7 minutes 95%, at 9 minutes 81%, at 12 minutes 52%, at 16 minutes 17%
What a grocery shop is worth in the score by type and minutes on foot. A supermarket nine minutes away is worth more than the shop by the door.

First place matters more than second

The need does not look at one shop but at the best three. The best gives 70% of the score, the second 20%, the third 10%. "Best" means the most valuable, not the closest. So a supermarket seven minutes away comes first and the shop downstairs second.

This leads to something unexpected. An address with only corner shops nearby can never score more than 75 out of 100 for this need, however many such shops there are. Three shops by the door give 0.7 × 75 + 0.2 × 75 + 0.1 × 75 = 75. To go higher you need at least one supermarket or market.

The reverse example. Say a building has only one shop nearby, a supermarket five minutes away. It gives 70 out of 100, and the second and third places are empty. One good shop is not yet a full score: the calculation values choice.

A small market in an old Tbilisi neighbourhood: stalls of fruit and herbs among houses with wooden balconies.

Tbilisi: the market is closer, but the supermarket comes first

At 12 Rustaveli Avenue the report shows this. The nearest place for groceries is a market 312 metres away, 3.9 minutes on foot. The Goodwill supermarket is further: 541 metres and 6.8 minutes. Yet the supermarket is first in the count.

PlaceTypeOn footValueSharePoints
Goodwillsupermarket541 m, 6.8 min0.97670%68.3
unnamed marketmarket312 m, 3.9 min0.820%16.0
Carrefour Marketsupermarket812 m, 11.2 min0.75410%7.5
12 Shota Rustaveli Avenue, Tbilisi, report of 4 October 2026, General profile. Minutes are "counts as", including crossings and climbs.

Tbilisi is a large city with a metro, so Goodwill at 6.8 minutes keeps almost all its value, 0.976. The market at 3.9 minutes counts in full by minutes, but its quality is 0.8, so it comes second. Third is Carrefour Market, 812 metres away. The total is 91.8 out of 100: a good result, even though there is no supermarket within five minutes.

Within walking distance the map knows 237 places where you can buy groceries. But three of them go into the score, and rightly so: the tenth shop in the neighbourhood changes nothing about where you go for milk.

When there is no shop at all

A grocery shop is an essential need in every profile. If there is no place to buy groceries within walking distance, the Groceries category loses the weight of this need and another 40% of what is left. An address with a bakery but not a single shop gets 15 out of 100 in Groceries, not 25.

Here a corner shop is irreplaceable. Even with a quality of 0.75 it removes this penalty entirely: the essential need is covered. That is why the gap between "nothing at all" and "a corner shop" is much bigger than the gap between "a corner shop" and "a supermarket".

Bakeries and shopping centres count separately

Fresh bread is a separate need, Fresh food, in the same category. It takes bakeries, pastry shops and delicatessens, and cheese shops and sweet shops with a quality of 0.7. Its window is shorter: full value up to five minutes, nothing from fifteen. At Rustaveli 12 there is a bakery 143 metres away, and the need scored 100.

A shopping centre belongs to another category, Services nearby, and its window is wider: full value up to eight minutes.

What the calculation does not know about shops

  • Prices. A discounter and an expensive food hall tagged "supermarket" are worth the same.
  • Size. A small supermarket and a hypermarket look the same on the map if they were tagged the same way.
  • Opening hours. A corner shop open around the clock gets no bonus for it.
  • Range. If you need halal, kosher or gluten-free food, add your own shop to My places.

The type of shop is taken from the open map as people tagged it. Sometimes a corner shop is tagged as a supermarket, and the other way round. The report shows the name and type of every place it counted, and they are worth reading.

All kinds of places and their quality are listed on the page How it is calculated. More addresses in the Georgian capital are on the Tbilisi page, and the best addresses in the country are in the rating.

Questions

Which is better for the score: a supermarket or a corner shop?

A supermarket is worth 1, a corner shop 0.75. A supermarket nine minutes away outside a large city is worth 0.81, more than the shop by your door.

Can groceries score 100 without a supermarket?

No, if there are only corner shops nearby: 75 at most. A market is worth 0.8 and gives up to 80.

How many shops does the calculation count?

The three most valuable: the first gives 70% of the score, the second 20%, the third 10%. The rest do not enter the score.